Billy Collins (Ed)
Category: Poetry; Animals (Birds)
Synopsis: Former
poet laureate Collins presents poems about birds.
Date finished: 2 September 2014
Rating: ***
Comments:
I imagined that I would love this book. I love poetry. I
love birds. And I love Billy Collins. So a book of bird poems edited by Billy
Collins seemed an enjoyment no-brainer. Unfortunately, not so much. While I
enjoyed the book, it didn’t “burn me down” as my old poetry professor told us good
poetry should. There was a candle flicker occasionally, but no roaring fire.
Now, I was impressed by the sheer number of poems in this
collection. And almost all of them were poems I didn’t know. No Poe’s “The Raven.”
(But he did include Wallace Stevens’s “Thirteen Ways of Looking at a Blackbird”
and Mary Oliver’s “Wild Geese.”) There are old and contemporary poets. It
really is a good mix.
The pictures, though, blew me away. Some of them really are
breathtaking. The illustrations are done by America’s foremost bird
illustrator, David Allen Sibley. And each bird represented in poetry is
depicted in artwork and accompanied by a short dossier of the bird. It’s all
printed on good, heavy, glossy paper. And I really like the size of the book.
(When it comes to poetry, it’s as much about the presentation as the thing
being presented.)
One quibble I had—and perhaps I missed something—is that the
poems/birds seemed to be in no particular order. All of the poems about a bird
(cardinals, for example) were together, but there seemed to be no method to the
presentation. I expected to see all the songbirds together, all the birds of
prey, all the waterfowl, etc. Granted, I don’t know much about bird orders, but
it didn’t seem logically organized. (Although it might have been, for all I
know.)
But overall, it really is an elegant and sophisticated
little collection. And I found some real gems. But the ratio of gems to “ehs”
was too low to make it a favorite anthology.
Would you recommend
this to a friend?
This would be a beautiful gift for a birder or poet in your
life.
You might also enjoy:
Aimless Love, Billy CollinsDog Songs, Mary Oliver
No comments:
Post a Comment